Only Education
Law

Allahabad HC Hearing in CLAT 2026 Revised Merit Case Continues

tulika sinha

Published 18 Feb 20265 min read

Allahabad High Court Hearing on CLAT 2026 Revised Merit List
As of February 18, 2026, the Allahabad High Court continues to hear the special appeal regarding the CLAT 2026 merit list revision. The Consortium of National Law Universities has challenged the single-bench order that mandated a recalculation of ranks due to a disputed logical reasoning question. While admissions from the first two rounds remain protected, the third merit list for undergraduate courses is currently on hold pending a final judicial verdict. Legal arguments are focusing on the Oversight Committee's decision to overrule expert advice without providing documented justifications.

The Allahabad High Court is currently presiding over a high-stakes legal battle that has brought the undergraduate law admission cycle to a temporary standstill. As of today, February 18, 2026, the Division Bench is hearing the Special Appeal (No. 135 of 2026) filed by the Consortium of National Law Universities (NLUs). The litigation stems from a previous single-bench directive that ordered a total revision of the CLAT 2026 merit list. The primary point of contention is Question No. 9 of Booklet C (Question No. 91 of Master Booklet A), where the court found that two options should be treated as correct. This judicial intervention has forced the Consortium to defer the third seat allotment list, affecting thousands of aspirants awaiting their turn in the 2026-27 admission session.

1. Core Legal Issues and Oversight Committee Discrepancies

The ongoing litigation centers on a procedural infirmity identified by the single-judge bench. During the initial hearing, it was revealed that an Expert Committee had recommended awarding marks for two separate options for a logical reasoning question, but this was later overruled.

  • Expert Recommendation: A panel of subject matter experts initially concluded that both options ‘B’ and ‘D’ were technically accurate for the disputed question.
  • Oversight Reversal: The Consortium's Oversight Committee reportedly discarded this expert view and retained only one correct option without recording specific administrative reasons.
  • Judicial Observation: The Court noted that while it generally stays out of academic matters, it must interfere when an "Oversight Committee" acts arbitrarily without assigning justifications for reversing expert findings.
  • Impacted Candidates: The litigation was initiated by a minor candidate, Avneesh Gupta, who argued that the incorrect evaluation significantly lowered his rank and denied him a seat at his preferred National Law University.

2. Impact on Counselling Schedule and Allotted Seats

As the litigation continues, the Consortium has taken steps to protect the interests of students who have already secured their positions. The Official Notification clarifies that the first two rounds of counselling are legally insulated from the outcome of this case.

Counselling RoundStatus as of Feb 18Judicial Impact
Round 1 AllotmentCompletedFully Protected
Round 2 AllotmentCompletedFully Protected
Round 3 AllotmentDeferredPending Verdict
Revised Merit ListPending AppealUnder Contention
  • Seat Protection: The Court has explicitly clarified that students who have already taken admission pursuant to the first round of counselling shall not be disturbed by any future merit list revision.
  • Third List Postponement: Originally scheduled for February 5, the release of the third merit list remains suspended until the Division Bench provides a definitive ruling on the litigation.
  • Consortium’s Defense: The Consortium of NLUs is defending the "Final Answer Key" to ensure academic uniformity across all future rounds, citing the need for a stable admission framework.
  • Waitlisted Aspirants: Thousands of students in the "float" category are currently in a state of uncertainty as the rankings may shift if the order for a revised merit list is upheld.

3. Procedural Delays and Next Hearing Milestones

The case status for SPLA 135/2026 remains "Pending" as the court navigates the complex arguments presented by both the litigation counsel and the Consortium’s legal team. Recent updates indicate that the matter has been "Passed Over" in some sessions due to a heavy roster.

  • Jurisdictional Debate: The Consortium initially challenged the Allahabad High Court’s jurisdiction, but the court ruled that since the exam was conducted in Ghaziabad, a part of the cause of action arose within its territory.
  • Stay Application: The Consortium has filed an urgent stay application (IA/2/2026) to halt the immediate implementation of the merit list revision while the appeal is heard.
  • Division Bench Roster: The case is currently tied to a specific Division Bench, ensuring that the same judges continue to hear the intricate details of the contention.
  • Revised Calendar: Once a verdict is delivered, the Consortium will be required to publish an updated counselling calendar within 48 to 72 hours to resume seat allotments.

Conclusion

As of February 18, 2026, the CLAT 2026 contention remains the most significant legal hurdle for law admissions in India. The outcome of this litigation will decide whether the merit list needs a massive recalculation for the third and subsequent rounds of counselling. For the Consortium, the goal is to maintain the finality of their expert-led evaluation, while for the petitioners, it is a fight for rank accuracy. Aspirants are advised to ignore rumors and rely only on Official Notifications regarding the revised schedule. The court's final decision is expected to provide much-needed clarity, allowing the 2026-27 batch to finally settle into their respective campuses by the July commencement date.

For regular updates follow Only Education News. For more details on law entrance exams and courses, check here: Law Exams List.

Related Shorts

SLAT 2027 Registration Started 🚨 | Exam Dates, Fees, Eligibility & Symbiosis Law Admission
Shorts

SLAT 2027 Registration Started 🚨 | Exam Dates, Fees, Eligibility & Symbiosis Law Admission

Want to pursue Law from Symbiosis after Class 12th? ⚖️ SLAT 2027 registration has started, and students targeting Symbiosis Law School Pune, Noida, Hyderabad or Nagpur should know the complete admission schedule. In this video, we cover the key details of the Symbiosis Law Admission Test (SLAT 2027) including registration dates, exam pattern, eligibility, fees, two-attempt rule, admit cards and result date. 📌 SLAT 2027 Important Dates 🔹 Application Last Date: 4 December 2026 🔹 SLAT Test 1: 19 December 2026 🔹 SLAT Test 2: 26 December 2026 🔹 Test 1 Admit Card: 11 December 2026 🔹 Test 2 Admit Card: 18 December 2026 🔹 SLAT 2027 Result: 12 January 2027 📚 Exam Pattern 60 Questions | 60 Minutes | 60 Marks ✅ Legal Reasoning ✅ Logical Reasoning ✅ Analytical Reasoning ✅ Reading Comprehension ✅ General Knowledge ✅ No Negative Marking Students can appear for both SLAT 2027 attempts, and the higher score will be considered for further evaluation. 💰 SLAT 2027 Fees Entrance Test Fee: ₹2,250 per test Programme Registration Fee: ₹1,000 per programme After qualifying SLAT, shortlisted candidates will also have to appear for the Personal Interaction (PI) round as part of the Symbiosis Law School admission process. 📲 Subscribe to Only Education for verified updates on SLAT 2027, law entrance exams, BA LLB admission, BBA LLB admission, college admissions and entrance exam deadlines. #SLAT2027 #SymbiosisLaw #SLATRegistration #SymbiosisLawSchool #LawEntranceExam #BALLB #BBALLB #LawAdmission2027 #LawAspirants #EntranceExam2027 #CollegeAdmission2027 #OnlyEducation